Mac's "Science is a liar sometimes" presentation

3 claims checked: 1 supported, 1 missing context, 1 misleading. Sources on screen as it plays.

Watch on YouTube

Fact checks

  1. 0:10 “he believed that the earth was the”

    Supported. Aristotle's On the Heavens set out a geocentric cosmos with a stationary spherical Earth at its center.

    Sources: On the Heavens, Cosmology - StarChild - NASA, aristotle_cosmology_summarized.html

  2. 0:20 “another smartest guy came around galileo and he disproved that theory”

    Missing context. Galileo's Venus phases and Jupiter's moons refuted the Ptolemaic/Aristotelian geocentric model, but Tycho's geocentric model survived until later evidence.

    Sources: Galileo affair, Visible Stars as Apparent Observational Evidence in Favor of the Copernican Principle in the Early 17th Century, Planetary Motion: The History of an Idea That Launched the Scientific Revolution - NASA Science

  3. 1:02 “he also thought he could turn metal into gold and died eating mercury”

    Misleading. Newton pursued alchemy, and his hair showed high mercury, but he died in his sleep at 84 in 1727; mercury as cause of death is unproven.

    Sources: How Did Isaac Newton Die? Cause of Death Explained, Later life of Isaac Newton, Newton's Death - Isaac Newton

Fack'dReal-time fact checks for live news
Sign in

Plan and pricing Admin panel Sign out

Fack’d: real-time fact checks for live news. This county debate is fictional.

Fictional debate · not live
HCTV
Fack'd

Checked claims, not every statement. Ratings apply to claims, never people. Every check cites the sources its search returned.

fackd.com

Checks show here as claims are made.

Load a clip to replay it with live checks.

A debate, a panel, a press conference. The file stays in your browser; only short audio chunks go to the server for transcription.

Live mic listens to the room. Put your phone or laptop near the TV.

0:00 Ready

Live checking is invite-only.

Fact checks

Checks show up here with their sources, newest first.

Fack’d rates claims, never people. Checks can be wrong; flag any card that is. The county debate and its speakers, figures and sources are fictional.

Claims by speaker

Checked claims, not every statement. Ratings apply to claims, never people. Talk time is approximate.

0lines heard
0claims
0checked
–median s to check

Community

Think the rating is wrong? Flag the check instead: a comment doesn't change it.

0:00

Transcript

You’ll post as

Shown instead of your name or email

Talk about claims, not people. Bring a source when you can.

What’s wrong with this comment?

The author won’t see who reported it.

Report a problem

A wrong or unfair check, a bug, or an idea. It goes straight to the Fack’d team.

Fact-checking new videos opens soon

Today Fack’d plays the fact checks it already has. Leave your email and we'll tell you the day you can check any video yourself.

Fack the whole video

Keep fact-checking

That was your 10 free checks. Premium checks 5 hours of new video a month for $12, and videos already checked always play free.

  • Premium, $12 a month: 5 hours of new video a month.
  • Pro, $49 a month: 20 hours a month, for checking every day.
See plans

You’re out of free checks