The Affordable Care Act’s Backstory | Obama’s Deal (full documentary) | FRONTLINE (PBS)

15 claims checked: 8 supported, 3 missing context, 1 misleading, 2 false, 1 unverifiable. Sources on screen as it plays.

Watch on YouTube

Fact checks

  1. 2:28 “The White House had a debate about whether they should actually go forward with it.”

    Supported. Reporting and aides' accounts show Biden and Emanuel urged caution or scaling back, so the White House did debate whether to pursue reform.

    Sources: The Inside Account of Health Care Reform's Triumph, Transcript, What Biden Really Said About Obamacare — And What It Might Say About His Potential Presidency

  2. 2:32 Narrator: “No president had ever made headway on comprehensive health care reform.”

    Missing context. Truman, Nixon and Clinton failed on universal coverage, but LBJ signed Medicare and Medicaid in 1965, a major health reform.

    Sources: A history of US health care from Medicare to Obamacare to Berniecare, Health Care in America, VIEW: Timeline: History of Health Reform in the U.S. Early 1900's 1930

  3. 2:36 “First, it became, Let's not do health care. Then it was, Scale health care back.”

    Missing context. Advisers (Biden, Emanuel) urged dropping or scaling back reform, but Obama rejected abandoning it; the quote is from Frontline's 2010 account.

    Sources: Transcript, The Inside Account of Health Care Reform's Triumph, www.pbs.org

  4. 3:48 Narrator: “Emmanuel told Obama to win he needed to move fast.”

    Supported. Emanuel, as incoming chief of staff, urged using the 2008 crisis to act fast; the exact private advice is plausible but not verbatim sourced.

    Sources: Do Not Waste This Crisis, Obama Taking Advantage of the Crisis

  5. 5:29 Narrator: “Sixteen years ago, he worked in the Clinton administration.”

    False. Emanuel served in the Clinton White House 1993–1998; in 2010 he was Obama's chief of staff. "Sixteen years" fits 1993 from a 2009 clip.

    Sources: Rahm Emanuel Fast Facts, Rahm Emanuel, Rahm Emanuel - Ballotpedia

  6. 7:21 Narrator: “as President Obama's chief of staff”

    Supported. Emanuel was Obama's White House chief of staff from January 20, 2009 to October 1, 2010, then left to run for Chicago mayor.

    Sources: Rahm Emanuel Fast Facts, Rahm Emanuel, Rahm Emanuel

  7. 9:39 Narrator: “Baucus allowed Republicans on the committee to tear into Daschle's personal finances.”

    Misleading. Baucus publicly backed Daschle and Daschle withdrew Feb 3, 2009, before the Feb 10 hearing; Republicans only questioned him in a closed meeting.

    Sources: After closed meeting, Dems close ranks behind Daschle - Government Executive, Tax Uproar Drives Out Daschle - Roll Call, Dems Speak Up Daschle, GOP Senators Mum - CBS News

  8. 10:30 “the reason that Tom Dashiell did not make it through the confirmation process is because Max Baucus gave him such a hard time dragging out the confirmation and the details and all the financial disclosures.”

    False. Baucus publicly backed Daschle, said he expected confirmation, and Daschle withdrew Feb. 3, 2009, over unpaid taxes; no record of Baucus stalling.

    Sources: Daschle faces more questions on nomination, Tax Uproar Drives Out Daschle - Roll Call, Daschle Withdraws Nomination for Health and Human Services Secretary

  9. 12:05 “of these players for years, if not decades, had a record of opposing any sort of health care reform efforts.”

    Missing context. Many stakeholders, notably the AMA, insurers and drug and hospital lobbies, long opposed reform; the source says "many," not all, and doesn't name nurses.

    Sources: www.pbs.org, Healthcare reform: Obama cut private deals with likely foes - CSMonitor.com, AMA Opposition to Obama Public Health Plan Echoes Group’s Decades-Long Resistance to Healthcare Reform

  10. 13:48 Narrator: “She said she'd support the bill only if everyone was required to buy health insurance.”

    Supported. AHIP's Karen Ignagni said insurers would back guaranteed coverage only with an enforceable individual mandate; this was stated publicly, not just privately.

    Sources: Insurers pitch health coverage mandate, Insurers Say Democratic 'Villain' Comments Hurtful To Process - KFF Health News, Mandate To Buy Coverage: Health Insurance Industry's Idea, Not Obama's

  11. 15:26 “He's one of the senior most senators”

    Supported. Describing 2009: Baucus, in the Senate since 1978, was among its longest-serving members (fifth-longest by 2010); he left the Senate in 2014.

    Sources: Max Baucus — Senate Finance Committee, Max Baucus - Ballotpedia

  12. 18:43 Narrator: “Baucus and the White House were also secretly negotiating another deal.”

    Supported. Baucus and the White House negotiated an $80 billion drug-industry deal with PhRMA in spring 2009, announced publicly in June 2009.

    Sources: www.pbs.org, The Legacy of Billy Tauzin: The White House-PhRMA Deal : Sunlight Foundation, June 29, 2009

  13. 20:26 Narrator: “And just over a year later, Tozin was hired as the pharmaceutical industry's top lobbyist.”

    Supported. Bill signed Dec 8, 2003; PhRMA named Tauzin president and CEO on Dec 15, 2004, about a year and a week later (started Jan 2005).

    Sources: Medicare Prescription Drug, Improvement, and Modernization Act, Tauzin to Head Drug Trade Group (washingtonpost.com), Top House Republican becomes chief US drug company lobbyist - World Socialist Web Site

  14. 22:18 Narrator: “He proposed a complicated formula which he said would cut drug costs by $80,000,000,000 over ten years.”

    Supported. PBS Frontline's chronology says PhRMA's Billy Tauzin proposed a deal with a complicated formula he said would cut drug costs $80B over 10 years.

    Sources: Chronology, Pharmaceutical Industry Keeps Hand In Health Care Bill: Interview With Billy Tauzin - KFF Health News

Fack'dReal-time fact checks for live news
Sign in

Plan and pricing Admin panel Sign out

Fack’d: real-time fact checks for live news. This county debate is fictional.

Fictional debate · not live
HCTV
Fack'd

Checked claims, not every statement. Ratings apply to claims, never people. Every check cites the sources its search returned.

fackd.com

Checks show here as claims are made.

Load a clip to replay it with live checks.

A debate, a panel, a press conference. The file stays in your browser; only short audio chunks go to the server for transcription.

Live mic listens to the room. Put your phone or laptop near the TV.

0:00 Ready

Live checking is invite-only.

Fact checks

Checks show up here with their sources, newest first.

Fack’d rates claims, never people. Checks can be wrong; flag any card that is. The county debate and its speakers, figures and sources are fictional.

Claims by speaker

Checked claims, not every statement. Ratings apply to claims, never people. Talk time is approximate.

0lines heard
0claims
0checked
–median s to check

Community

Think the rating is wrong? Flag the check instead: a comment doesn't change it.

0:00

Transcript

You’ll post as

Shown instead of your name or email

Talk about claims, not people. Bring a source when you can.

What’s wrong with this comment?

The author won’t see who reported it.

Report a problem

A wrong or unfair check, a bug, or an idea. It goes straight to the Fack’d team.

Fact-checking new videos opens soon

Today Fack’d plays the fact checks it already has. Leave your email and we'll tell you the day you can check any video yourself.

Fack the whole video

Keep fact-checking

That was your 10 free checks. Premium checks 5 hours of new video a month for $12, and videos already checked always play free.

  • Premium, $12 a month: 5 hours of new video a month.
  • Pro, $49 a month: 20 hours a month, for checking every day.
See plans

You’re out of free checks